JWP
I do not know Wildcat and could care less, I got ****ed when the the Kirby PR and Marketing team led by you and a couple others post "what a joke" thread denigrating a highly respected smith Richard Franklin who does not posting here, (he is too busy building some of the best guns anywhere to include here) then try to make it about safety later when it never was about that because you said it was not possible. That was the genisis of your post and nothing else!!! So too **** late to try and take the safety high road now.
Your original Joke posting was probably the absolutely lowest class, meanest, despicable posting I have ever seen. Some here have smartly backed off from it but you and a couple others keep on attacking Wildcat, the cartridge and in effect Richard Franklin. This thread alone proves my point with the outright lies, and lowclass attacks being made.
When it was shown that over 30 plus guns had been build and doing it safety you and the other LR PC police tried to fall back on the "safety ploy" and say someone "could do something dumb and get hurt". DUH, that is on any cartridge. Man you have got to be grossly naive and flat out stupid to think Paul on 6mmBR would post that article without checking it out and that 30 plus "unsafe" guns are out there ( as you basically claimed) with no ramifications.
There was not one posting anywhere about Richard stating that you could get 4000fps in the 700 action, only at tops 3800. Why don't we use that same standard now on the wildcats being posted here that "could" be overloaded as all of you claim the 300 Varminter could. Stupid is stupid no matter what the cartridge is and who makes the gun.
As for my comments on the Lapua were quoting Dan Liljas article on that very subject every time, so suppose you want to personnally attack him now too. I also posted that I recently talked with the Chandlers who claim that they did the testing for Rem with the Lapua and went up over 100k repeatedly before it showed any stress. Is that true, maybe, maybe not.
So what is the danger again with the Varminter at 3800 in a 700? Feel free to have one of the "marketing reps" run it thru Quickload as no 700 loads have ever been posted that I have seen so I am interested in seeing what unsafe load someone dreams up to run thru. Be sure and use the default settings on seating that might be artificially high as no one here knows what the real ones are. Lets just "assume" and attack like you did. While your at it maybe your could alter the bullet friction coefficiant to get a higher PSI.
Maybe you want to claim again you talked to a three "ballistics labs" and post with the clear inference that they somehow tested the Varminter and found it unsafe, when in reality you only called three bullet mftr companies, and they gave you the book answer for stock guns applicable only to the configuration they tested. Two of them did not even quote from their own book, but used someone elses. The one that emailed me and you advertised a year or so on thier website for "an experienced reloader" to do their ballistics testing for them. No engineer, just an experienced reloader. In reality that is all they really needed too, but that sure is not a "ballistics lab" as you posted. That alone shows the depth you will lower yourself to to denigrate Franklin.
What IF we adopted your standards and started attacking Kirby for his line of cartridges? We have wildcat cartridges being touted here every day off cases that are not SAAMI spec'd, never been pressure tested only eyeball pressure testing, numerous postings show loads are listed using old surplus powders that are extremely sensitive to temp variations (talk about unsafe practives using surplus powders and novice reloaders, that is the poster child) which are unsafe in different weather conditions as from summer to winter; postings show the assumption of 68,000 PSI operationg loads on cases that never tested and that some sources show as low as 62K, use limited access bullets that simple bullet substitution might put you over the danger threshhold. You guys would squeal like stuck pigs.
Are they safe? Absolutely, handled and loaded correctly. Are they dangerous? Absolutely again, if someone does something stupid. The WSM Varminter is no different! If wildcatting rely on your smiths knowledge and work the load up slowly. Stupid will hurt you no matter what cartridge it is. No one should take any souped up wildcat cartridge and start at the top as you claimed "could be done". If that was the standard, no wildcats for sure could be touted here.
Now Remington is selling the 700 in the 338 Lapua and Oh my god, someone could load that case to over spec in one of the wildcat cases here and put it on a Remington but that is OK? The WSM case is SAAMI spec the highest of any commercal case that has been tested at 65,000 plus that means another 25% on top of that which puts its tested limit at 83,000. A few cases are equal, maybe others are higher and maybe not, yet the PC police do not see a problem with untested wildcat cartridges being touted at 68000 (normal operating pressure).
Why don't you hold those cartridges to the same standard? We are all supposed to just accept them as blind gospel while you and 3-4 other PC police denigrate others. Hmm, maybe real safety "for all" cartridges is not your real intent it could be said.
This never was about safety and your first thread on it shows it. It was about denigrating a respected smith that just is not your priest and shows the absolute despicable manner that you and others adopted doing it.
If you do not like Wildcats post, sit back and lay off the keyboard and he will quit posting. He is only posting because you and others are not smart enough to see he is pulling your chain and you stupidly jump in each time ridiculing and denigrating him.
Bottom line this has been nothing other than blatant hypocricy, bullying, low class of the PC police (same 3-5 individuals) and I am going to call you on it every time. If you do not like it, too **** bad, get used to it every time you jump out there and pull that lowlife crap. Now if you want to act and treat others with a degree of respect that is fine with me, I prefer it that way. However, base on what I am seeing, attack of the lowlifes will continue.
BH