I've killed deer with the 100 gr Sierras, 100 gr ballistic tips, 100 gr Barnes, 115 gr ballistic tips, 115 Bergers, 110 gr Accubonds, probably a couple others.
Out of the 257 Wby, it really depends on what your rifle likes. They all kill, the monos and bonded seemed to kill a little slower to me.
The 115 grain Bergers really "slaps them down" with a loud wack!
The 110 grain Accubonds, only killed two bucks with them and was disappointed. The only deer I've ever seen take more than a couple stumbling steps after being hit with the big 257. One buck ran about 40 yards and the other went about 120 yards.
Thought I missed the sob.
You want them to drop right now? Shoot them with a 100 grain lead core bullet.
Just my experiences,
Gary