In Wisconsin your are most likely going to be playing to an audience of local shooters/hunters. Myself, I would buy tickets on a Weatherby not necessarily a belted magnum but a .270 or a .284 or a 6.5CM or a 7mm-08 would get my attention, reasonably priced, reliable and a quality piece, or a Tikka, in similar calibers. If you are in centerfire country a lever action Henry in 30-30 will get a lot of action as well.
I was in a raffle once that had a Cooper in .270 Weatherby Mag, At the time they sold for around $2k I bought 4 $100 tickets and won the rifle. I had Cooper convert it back to a .270win and life is good.
There are some really quality Over/Under shotguns from Turkey that have come on the market lately. Along with Ruger's offerings.
I'm always in on 1911's in .45acp. Colt, Remington, Springfield, Rock Island, Ruger.