Observations from my elk hunt...

crazyhorse

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
351
Location
southeast
Just returned from my NM elk hunt and had thoughts of topics often discussed here along the way. I'll admit, not only have I read all the bullet performance threads pertaining to on game performance, I even started one. Lots of good information on this forum based on solid knowledge and experience. Anyway, I thought I'd share my experiences on what turned out to be a hunt of a lifetime.

I carried my 300WM that had been shooting lights out with the 215 Bergers. Sometime in the last couple of range trips it started acting goofy throwing 1 in 3 about an inch out of an otherwise 1/2 moa group. The outfitter told me shots range from 100-600yds and my ability to over think everything caused me to go back to the drawing board. I loaded up a handful of 200g ELD-X's I had previously managed to shoot really well. As luck would have it they picked up right where they left off and shot very consistent out to 1200yds. I recorded my dope and headed west hoping the ELD-X would hold up if I got the chance.

The first morning brought good weather and as soon as the sun started breaking we were finding elk in the lower areas still feeding. We found a really nice bull with 7 cows and decided to try and make a move. He was a little over a mile away but in a drainage we felt would give us a chance based on the wind. As we started making our way towards him we found a spike bull and a young 3x3 feeding and stoppped to avoid spooking them and blowing everything out of the area. While waiting on them to clear I noticed the tops of what appeared to be another really nice bull feeding just below them in the oak brush. He raised his head and I knew immediately he was one I wanted to shoot.

We were on a high spot and he was across a wash just slightly higher than us feeding along totally unaware of our presence. Using my pack under ny bipods I was able to get in position and wait for a clear shot. 20 minutes seemed like 2hrs as we only got partial views and hard quartering angles as he fed along the hillside. Seeing a clearing ahead I ranged it hoping he would continue along his path and give me a shot. Sure enough he stepped out and I ranged him at just shy of 400yds. He was slightly quartering away giving me a really good look. I pressed the trigger and he dropped as if unplugged! I ran the bolt and watched him kick and attempt to lift his head for just a few seconds until he lay still and I knew it was done.

He started as a 5x6 but had broken off two of his eye guards, one on each side (we couldn't see it due to the brief intermittent views) making him a 4x5 but roughly a 290-300 class bull before the damage.

To make an already long story short, I was shooting the 200gr ELD-X behind 72gr of H4831SC doing a verified average of 3012fps. The shot was 392yds landing in the crease just behind the shoulder and a touch high probably 6" below the back line. As I mentioned earlier the bull dropped immediately on the shot and was done within just a few seconds. When we started breaking him down I paid particular attention to the bullet performance and found some interesting results.
Entry was caliber size with no exit but the lungs were absolute mush. The bullet caught a partial rib entering and didn't even bruise the interior of the offside rib cage. I'm certainly not complaining because I had a very dead elk without as much as a step but was shocked a bullet weighing 200 grains exploded so violently even at 400yds.

Soon as I can get pics from my phone to my iPad I'll add them here. Awesome hunt and an awesome animal! I'll be back every time I get the chance but I'll have the 215 Bergers or the Hammer's ready for the next one, it concerns me to think about the ELD if I'd have caught heavy bone.
 
Sounds like a great hunt. I had the same worries about the eldx myself. But then again I have the same fear of the Berger Bullets also. That being said it's hard to deny how well and fast they kill when used correct. I think it comes down to the ones that do t hit where you should. I was running the eld for a bit because the thicker jacket. While I was explaining it to a group of gentleman who questioned my choice while at a ranch in Texas. The usually quite guide spoke up and said only one bullet concerns him and it was Berger.
He stated that they are amazing Bullets and he indeed like them but said that the heavy skinned African game. Larger stuff I presume was very hard on those Bullets. Which means the eldx May be the same issue.
Also not trying to start a debate because I had not had personal experience just observation that made sense to me much like the OP thinking choice through.
This type of real world stories like your and his makes sense.
Pick the right tool for the job. When it comes to North American game we can use a bit softer bullet than tends to come along with long range Bullets.
Congrats on the hunt.
 
I had same issue with eld-x also. Dead is dead but I have had issues with those and bergers at times. I'm going back to AB and or TTSX. I havent had any issues with those ever and I get blood trails.
 
IMG_0078.PNG
Finally got a pic converted! He's not a world record by any means but I sure am proud.
Didn't find any bullet fragment as we used the gutless method. Peering down through the entrance during skinning showed the lungs to be soup and not a scratch on the offside rib cage.

My outfitter wasn't a gun guy but did request I shoot him through the shoulders for a quick kill. I agreed knowing that wasn't going to happen if I had time to pick my shot. Just in the crease behind the shoulder and he fell like a wet towel. Just a tiny bit of bloodshot meat in the base of his neck presumably from a piece of frag that went that way.
 
Warning! This thread is more than 5 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.
Top