Sounds like most scope reviews pretty much. Reviews are typically split. I will say based on the Mueller scopes I've seen on rifles owned by people at my range, they work well for the $$$. Michigan based company so I bought one and haven't regretted it. Figured it would take a crap after a couple years on a muzzleloader but after over 10 years, still going strong. Personally can't ask for more than that. I wouldn't probably buy another as I've pretty much called Sightron my go to scope on all my guns today. I have zero regrets owning mine tho.