Mud Runner2005,
Its not unusual to get different OAL lengths when using any type of OAL tool as its virtually impossible to apply the same pressure to the bullet each time. Also the more you measure with the same bullet the farther it goes into the lands due to the soft copper jacket. What I do when using either the Sinclair or Hornady tools is to run some dry patches down the barrel first to remove any oil in the barrel or in the chamber. When doing the bullet insert up to the lands part of the operation the bullet is pushed in lightly until I feel it stop. When I get to the building the dummy round step I use a once fired neck sized round, the bullet used to get the measurements and seat the bullet to the sum of the measurements found. Then take some 0000 steel wool , polish the tarnish off the bullet and chamber the dummy round slowly in the rifle , extract it and check the bullet for lands marks. If The barrel is a 4 groove you want to see 4 lands marks on the bullet, 5 groove 5 and so on. The lands marks will probably have some length on them depending on the pressure used during the measurement phase. Now adjust the seater stem down slightly, polish the bullet again , seat the bullet a little deeper and recheck the lands marks. Repeat until you end up with the lands marks on the bullet being about as thick as the point on a very sharp #2 pencil. You are still in the lands a little but if you go any deeper with the bullet you will use your reference point on the bullet. Now measure dummy round from base to ojive with a bullet comparator and calipers to get your comparator length to the lands. Keep this round and use it as a gauge to setup seating dies and to use to measure your throat wear. There are many ways get your OAL to the lands . I use this one.
If you need any more help please feel free to contact us! Thanks for using our bullets!
Take care,
Phil Hoham
Berger Bullet Tech