First off, I did not intend to offend, just point out that your comments could have been taken quite differently then you intended. I was not reved up in any way, just pointing out why your point of view may not fit for alot more shooters then you think.
I average around 85 rifles shipped a year to customers. Full custom rifles ranging from $3000 up to $8000 rifles. Of those fully 20% are for customers that do not handload and never plan to handload...... Those are just my own numbers and I fully explain the limitations they are imposing on themselves shooting factory ammo but the simple fact is, there is a sizable number of people out there that have no desire to handload for their rifles, weither it be a $500 Savage or a $5000 APS custom, some just do not handload and do not want to.
The 100 to 125 fps velocity average is not a number I made up, its what I have seen with actual rifles, dozens of them. THe longer the barrel and the heavier the bullet, the higher the velocity advantage will be for the larger capacity chamberings. Not an opinion, just the way it is.
I personally think the 338 RUM is a great round but if you load for the 338 RUM, you can get 100 fps more performance with same bullet weights with no more effort in any way using the Edge and with no extra cost at all except a pennies worth of extra powder maybe.
You say 100-125 fps is insignificant, well, perhaps but thats about the difference between the 280 Rem and 7mm Rem Mag, or the 7mm rem to the 7mm STW or the 7mm STW to the 7mm RUM or the 300 WIn Mag and 300 Wby mag, or the 300 Wby Mag and the 300 RUM.
Does this mean that all these are meaningless......
Point being, I offered other options which is what this board is supposed to be all about and you came in and said it would be "Nuts" to go with anything larger then the 338 RUM unless your going to improve the Lapua. My comments is simply that that is untrue. Not trying to offend in any way but its not your choice to tell everyone if 100 to 125 fps is worth the larger cases, its for the individual and what they want.
Will an elk be able to tell the difference between a RUM and Edge at 800 yards, NOPE!!! But he would not be able to tell the difference between a 338 Win Mag and 338 Allen Magnum at 800 yards either if the bullet is put on the same point through the vitals, dead is dead but being able to choose from a variaty of chamberings that will get the job done is what makes this sport so fun and enjoyable.