Jay,
I agree, the BDC reticles are nice, and you still have the option of dialing if you want.
The Exbal ballistic program I have works with them too, and if the reticle is located in the second focal plane all the better! Does the reticle retain the same spacing when zoomed in and out or does it get larger and smaller with the sight picture too?
I use the R2 reticle on the NF so I'm with you on the BDC advantage.
I have heard more complaints about Burris scopes than all other MFG's combined, and then some. I've heard the same exact thing about their customer service, and in that amount too. It seems something's up with their QC and when customer service is called upon they have horrible results in 90 percent of the complaints. That scares the crap out of me, and I'll wait until I hear things have changed in both areas before I buy one. I have no time for problems with scopes and certainly don't want to ever wonder how I'm going to be dealt with if I did, I spend way too much cash on one to take a chance on those things.
I think Leupold and NF see it as the top priority to simply amaze their customers with the quality and service they provide, they charge extra up front for it and most people understand this and want to pay for the extra warranty cost. If things aren't right the "first time" when they ship it out for sale the company can exceed the extra they charge for free warranty work in no time in repair cost, labor, shipping etc, thus their incentive is potential profit if they get it right the first time, assuring you and I a much higher quality product just as we expect. Burris doesn't seem to grasp this concept... yet. Everything I've read about Burris is they are hit or miss, if you miss they can leave a serious bad taste in your mouth when you're through, if it's ever resolved. Only on "occasion" someone had a good experience with them and the problem was corrected just as expected, and that wasn't but maybe 10% of the time though!
Good luck with yours, I have a 2-7 on a pistol I'm crossing my fingers I never have to send back. My complaint with it is the Posi-Lock don't let you dial the clicks without removing the cap on it and using a screwdriver to unlock it first... that don't work for me, even though I see the benifit it offers, much too limiting if you want to dial out to the target. For me, I would hate to not know the problems people have had with Burris and find out myself, this is the only reason I say any of this. If the problems weren't so hit and miss and the customer service was comparable to Lupy or NF I'd have a Black Diamond or two right now! Ian and others say the glass is outstandingly clear, and bright, now if they can get the rest together.
Take care,