entoptics
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 16, 2018
- Messages
- 878
Here's a relatively detailed description of my method for obtaining ballistic coefficient values using a LabRadar. I'm hoping that we as a community can start using a relatively standardized method to calculate B.C. and share those results. Something along the lines of the excellent Hammer Hunter load data thread.
I'm also hoping discussion can mostly avoid philosophical debates on the utility of B.C., manufacturer methods and motivations, etc, and focus on the nuts and bolts of the data gathering and processing using a LabRadar.
Perhaps with some good brainstorming, we can come up with a method that everyone who owns a LabRadar can use, so we can get some more "standardized" data out there. With that, we could begin to investigate variables like twist rate, velocity, and atmospheric conditions, and perhaps gain more insight on B.C. variability.
I also encourage anyone else with a method they use to start their own thread. Name it something easily searcheable with LabRadar and B.C. in the title though, so we can all find it and link it when searching and posting. I'm happy with my method, but no doubt others may have as good or better techniques they can share.
My method...
Tools you'll need...
1) LabRadar
2) An SD memory card installed while shooting. We want to use all the data we gather, not just the pre-programmed intervals that LR spits out (watch video for why that's a problem). A memory card is the only way to capture that on a LR.
3) Computer with Excel, Numbers, Open Office, etc. We're going to need to do a little data processing. My spreadsheet is attached below.
4) Weather monitoring tools. Kestrel, home weather meters, smart phone barometers, etc. We need reasonably accurate values for temperature, pressure, and humidity. These need to be at the shot location in real time.
5) Rifle, powder, bullets.
6) This one is the hardest to find...Primers.
7) JBM Ballistics free online calculator (their may be others, but this one works for me).
Setup
A) When programming your LabRadar, set the far velocity yardage to something MUCH greater than the unit will track.
The unit will stop tracking a few yards past whatever the furthest yardage you set. Instead, we want it to track as far as it can. I believe the maximum value you can set is 300 yards? For large diameter bullets (e.g. 44 mag, 50 BMG, etc), tracking often goes all the way to the maximum the software allows. I regularly get 130 yards with 0.264, and 180 yards with 0.308 diameter, though I shoot in an ideal area (see below).
B) If possible, set up your shooting lane with as little vegetation or obstacles as feasible.
Radar will bounce off anything in the cone, and this will reduce accuracy, precision, and tracking distance. I'm lucky enough to shoot in a wide open field, hence the great tracking I routinely get. Regardless, do your best to reduce interfering objects in the widest path you can to the target.
If you can't clear your shooting lane, I recommend just going out in your front yard and aiming the LabRadar straight up, and firing your rifle into the open air (assuming no trees, power lines, etc are going to interfere). Preferably you should use full auto like one does at a wedding celebration. You can get tons of data fast, and you don't have to worry about a backstop...
C) You need to get accurate atmospheric conditions at your location, though basic tools will do just fine. You just need Temp, Barometric Pressure, and Humidity (least important).
Get these values at your shooting position, and not some nearby place your phone weather app polled. Use actual station pressure (not corrected for sea level).
Take readings frequently, and record the time, particularly if the weather is changing (e.g. early morning, late evening). If the values are changing significantly during your session, LabRadar files have a time stamp, so use the environmental data you recorded closest to the shot when calculating B.C.
The B.C.calculation will be off roughly 0.001 (G1) per degree of temperature error, and .002 per 0.1 inHg pressure error. Small but significant if you just use a weather app that pulls data from an airport 15 miles away, or using data that you collected two hours ago before it got cloudy...
D) Aim and stabilize your LR carefully.
I highly recommend making or buying a sighting system. I epoxied a little piece of stainless tubing to my sighting V, carefully squared to the unit face, but you do you. For longer range tracking, aiming is important.
I have a gorilla pod tripod, but brace it all with small bag of lead shot on each leg. Probably 20 lbs on that sucker. Whatever you choose, make sure it isn't vibrating or getting off aim during tracking.
Check your aim periodically. I've lost entire strings of bullets because my LR wobbled off of aim because of my superb MBM brakes, an errant wind gust, or just poking buttons. I still got velocity readings, but not good tracking files.
E) Have your target a little further away than you can reliably track bullets if possible.
LabRadar will track through some types of targets (cardboard, foam board, maybe even wood/metal/unobtanium?), but the interference will degrade tracking. You're artificially limiting your tracking distance by placing a target between the bullet and the radar.
Here's how I setup. Note the clump of tall vegetation, just to the right of my shooting lane at the edge of where the tilled and harvested field meet about 30 yards out. That caused poorer than normal tracking for me during this session.
Data Extraction and Reduction
My spreadsheet is attached as a zip file below. When using my spreadsheet, you'll want to allow Macros (a pop up will show up when you open it). Excel (Microsoft in general) is pretty much the angry nanny of software, so if you don't have the option to unblock the macros when the spreadsheet opens, you can easily do so in the file properties (Click here for instructions on unblocking a file).
If you don't trust the macros, you can use it without them just fine, but will have to manually copy and paste data from the LabRadar file, and will lose the automatic sorting button.
Here is a YouTube video demonstrating the use of the spreadsheet and the free calculator from JBM Ballistics (Click Here for JBM). It's long and boring. It does point out some of the shortcomings in LabRadar's pre-programmed velocity interval data, which might be helpful to those who want accurate velocity readings, even if they don't plan to calculate B.C.
Concluding Remarks
This method is not as good as $100,000 dedicated doppler setups. It's only tracking for 100-200 yards after all. That said, if you're using G7 B.C., the velocity vs B.C. curve is usually pretty flat, so it should hold up to quite a ways out there.
This method is better than estimating the B.C. based on the bullet measurements.
This method is probably better than estimating the B.C. using shot drops (at least G7 B.C.), unless you have some serious skill, perfect weather, and lots of ammo. Since it's so easy, you should ideally be recording all the shots you are taking to confirm your D.O.P. E. at range, and calculating the B.C. (and velocity) simultaneously with both methods.
The more care you take in setting up your LabRadar for good tracking, collecting accurate environmental data, and thoughtfully inspecting the data, the better your results will be.
Now that I have my system down, setting up at the range only takes me 15 minutes or so. Culling the data and typing it into JBM takes about 1 minute per shot.
This method may seem a bit daunting to folks who don't use spreadsheets much, but it's no more daunting than telling a relatively new long range shooter how to calculate B.C. or "true" their velocity (bad idea) from shot drops.
My spreadsheet and data reduction is not the only way to do it. If you're an Excel whiz, please make your own and share. All you really need is way to get the best fit regression from the data array, and to use that to calculate the velocity at two points, and the distance between those two points.
Please let me know if you try this out, and if you have any troubles or questions.
I'm also hoping discussion can mostly avoid philosophical debates on the utility of B.C., manufacturer methods and motivations, etc, and focus on the nuts and bolts of the data gathering and processing using a LabRadar.
Perhaps with some good brainstorming, we can come up with a method that everyone who owns a LabRadar can use, so we can get some more "standardized" data out there. With that, we could begin to investigate variables like twist rate, velocity, and atmospheric conditions, and perhaps gain more insight on B.C. variability.
I also encourage anyone else with a method they use to start their own thread. Name it something easily searcheable with LabRadar and B.C. in the title though, so we can all find it and link it when searching and posting. I'm happy with my method, but no doubt others may have as good or better techniques they can share.
My method...
Tools you'll need...
1) LabRadar
2) An SD memory card installed while shooting. We want to use all the data we gather, not just the pre-programmed intervals that LR spits out (watch video for why that's a problem). A memory card is the only way to capture that on a LR.
3) Computer with Excel, Numbers, Open Office, etc. We're going to need to do a little data processing. My spreadsheet is attached below.
4) Weather monitoring tools. Kestrel, home weather meters, smart phone barometers, etc. We need reasonably accurate values for temperature, pressure, and humidity. These need to be at the shot location in real time.
5) Rifle, powder, bullets.
6) This one is the hardest to find...Primers.
7) JBM Ballistics free online calculator (their may be others, but this one works for me).
Setup
A) When programming your LabRadar, set the far velocity yardage to something MUCH greater than the unit will track.
The unit will stop tracking a few yards past whatever the furthest yardage you set. Instead, we want it to track as far as it can. I believe the maximum value you can set is 300 yards? For large diameter bullets (e.g. 44 mag, 50 BMG, etc), tracking often goes all the way to the maximum the software allows. I regularly get 130 yards with 0.264, and 180 yards with 0.308 diameter, though I shoot in an ideal area (see below).
B) If possible, set up your shooting lane with as little vegetation or obstacles as feasible.
Radar will bounce off anything in the cone, and this will reduce accuracy, precision, and tracking distance. I'm lucky enough to shoot in a wide open field, hence the great tracking I routinely get. Regardless, do your best to reduce interfering objects in the widest path you can to the target.
If you can't clear your shooting lane, I recommend just going out in your front yard and aiming the LabRadar straight up, and firing your rifle into the open air (assuming no trees, power lines, etc are going to interfere). Preferably you should use full auto like one does at a wedding celebration. You can get tons of data fast, and you don't have to worry about a backstop...
C) You need to get accurate atmospheric conditions at your location, though basic tools will do just fine. You just need Temp, Barometric Pressure, and Humidity (least important).
Get these values at your shooting position, and not some nearby place your phone weather app polled. Use actual station pressure (not corrected for sea level).
Take readings frequently, and record the time, particularly if the weather is changing (e.g. early morning, late evening). If the values are changing significantly during your session, LabRadar files have a time stamp, so use the environmental data you recorded closest to the shot when calculating B.C.
The B.C.calculation will be off roughly 0.001 (G1) per degree of temperature error, and .002 per 0.1 inHg pressure error. Small but significant if you just use a weather app that pulls data from an airport 15 miles away, or using data that you collected two hours ago before it got cloudy...
D) Aim and stabilize your LR carefully.
I highly recommend making or buying a sighting system. I epoxied a little piece of stainless tubing to my sighting V, carefully squared to the unit face, but you do you. For longer range tracking, aiming is important.
I have a gorilla pod tripod, but brace it all with small bag of lead shot on each leg. Probably 20 lbs on that sucker. Whatever you choose, make sure it isn't vibrating or getting off aim during tracking.
Check your aim periodically. I've lost entire strings of bullets because my LR wobbled off of aim because of my superb MBM brakes, an errant wind gust, or just poking buttons. I still got velocity readings, but not good tracking files.
E) Have your target a little further away than you can reliably track bullets if possible.
LabRadar will track through some types of targets (cardboard, foam board, maybe even wood/metal/unobtanium?), but the interference will degrade tracking. You're artificially limiting your tracking distance by placing a target between the bullet and the radar.
Here's how I setup. Note the clump of tall vegetation, just to the right of my shooting lane at the edge of where the tilled and harvested field meet about 30 yards out. That caused poorer than normal tracking for me during this session.
Data Extraction and Reduction
My spreadsheet is attached as a zip file below. When using my spreadsheet, you'll want to allow Macros (a pop up will show up when you open it). Excel (Microsoft in general) is pretty much the angry nanny of software, so if you don't have the option to unblock the macros when the spreadsheet opens, you can easily do so in the file properties (Click here for instructions on unblocking a file).
If you don't trust the macros, you can use it without them just fine, but will have to manually copy and paste data from the LabRadar file, and will lose the automatic sorting button.
Here is a YouTube video demonstrating the use of the spreadsheet and the free calculator from JBM Ballistics (Click Here for JBM). It's long and boring. It does point out some of the shortcomings in LabRadar's pre-programmed velocity interval data, which might be helpful to those who want accurate velocity readings, even if they don't plan to calculate B.C.
Concluding Remarks
This method is not as good as $100,000 dedicated doppler setups. It's only tracking for 100-200 yards after all. That said, if you're using G7 B.C., the velocity vs B.C. curve is usually pretty flat, so it should hold up to quite a ways out there.
This method is better than estimating the B.C. based on the bullet measurements.
This method is probably better than estimating the B.C. using shot drops (at least G7 B.C.), unless you have some serious skill, perfect weather, and lots of ammo. Since it's so easy, you should ideally be recording all the shots you are taking to confirm your D.O.P. E. at range, and calculating the B.C. (and velocity) simultaneously with both methods.
The more care you take in setting up your LabRadar for good tracking, collecting accurate environmental data, and thoughtfully inspecting the data, the better your results will be.
Now that I have my system down, setting up at the range only takes me 15 minutes or so. Culling the data and typing it into JBM takes about 1 minute per shot.
This method may seem a bit daunting to folks who don't use spreadsheets much, but it's no more daunting than telling a relatively new long range shooter how to calculate B.C. or "true" their velocity (bad idea) from shot drops.
My spreadsheet and data reduction is not the only way to do it. If you're an Excel whiz, please make your own and share. All you really need is way to get the best fit regression from the data array, and to use that to calculate the velocity at two points, and the distance between those two points.
Please let me know if you try this out, and if you have any troubles or questions.