Rifleman7,
The Gibbs is a parts special. The action came from a used Parker Hale Midland with a busted stock, the barrel - a shot out 308 match barrel with serious throat erosion ( I wish I knew who made this barrel), spare gunstock at a gunshow.
Bevon King in northern BC did the rechambering to Gibbs. Tom Norman in Abbotsford did the initial install and 308match rechamber (shot very well too, just wanted more poop for LR hunting). No action work done.
Goes to show that a good barrel, installed properly does more for accuracy then all the action tweaking, etc. out there. The lock up of the bolt is tight but wobbles like
The limiting factor in this rifle is not the bullets but the stock. Using a hunting style stock with a rounded forend, the groups are 25 to 50% bigger then the flat bottom BR style stock I also have for this action. All properly bedded of course.
This rifle has already shot in the .1's with the SST at 100yds.
So far, my experience with Hornady bullets is the opposite of yours. Most every rifle I use them in shoot better. Go figure. The Hornady bullets do have a much different profile and I feel they shoot best when the ogive is close to the lands. This is not always possible with certain throats/magazine combos.
These "long" throats would favor the Sierra, etc. that have the ogive closer to the point. Could explain why you are also having issues the the Ballistic Tip, another match accurate bullet. The bullets need to be fully engraved by the rifling before leaving the neck of the case.
Did I mention that I just shot a 3 rd group at 680yds, in no wind, that measured 2 3/8" widest spread. Second group, light gusty wind, had two inside 2" with the third 8" away (oops). Going to do lots more shooting with this rig to learn how to read the wind. Brass is LC69 military stuff, offset flash holes and all.
Stock shape and wind will do more to screw up an accurate rifle then all the brass prep put together. Of course, ammo must use good bullets and be assembled straight.
Jerry